One of the newer issues that emerged in the twentieth century is the idea of a non-fixed gender identity and the choice of choosing your gender. While transgender individuals have existed in many cultures, the concept of gender identity and fluidity is relatively new. It is not discussed by prominent Greek philosophers like Aristotle, Socrates, or Plato, nor is it found in the works of John Locke, the founder of liberalism.
So, what are the roots of this issue? Should one be able to choose their gender? What challenges does this idea present? Most importantly, where does Islam stand on this topic?
Changing Genders: How We Got Here
In the West, modern concepts often trace back to the Reformation, which sought to reduce the Church’s influence over people’s lives. However, two significant movements shaped the idea of gender identity:
1. Individualism: A 19th-century philosophy that values personal freedom over societal norms. It emphasises the right to define one’s beliefs, values, and identity.
2. Sexual Revolution: In the 1960s and 1970s, this movement expanded the idea of individual freedom to include sexuality and relationships. It challenged traditional norms, promoting the idea that people should be free to express their gender identities.
So, What Is Gender Identity All About?
The concept of gender identity, including transgenderism, is based on the distinction between sex and gender—two terms that are often used interchangeably. Understanding the distinction between the two terms is critical to grasping the modern perspective on gender identity:
- Sex: Refers to biological traits assigned at birth, like physical characteristics and reproductive organs, identifying individuals as male or female.
- Gender: A social concept that includes roles, behaviours, and identities linked to being male or female. It relates to how individuals see themselves, which might not match their biological sex.
Based on this idea, someone could be born male but identify as female, or vice versa. Gender identity isn’t limited to just male or female but can include other possibilities:
- Agender: Choosing no gender or being gender-neutral.
- Bigender: Identifying with both male and female genders.
- Genderqueer/Non-binary: Existing outside the traditional male-female binary.
Gender identity can also be fluid, changing over time or even daily. This concept, known as Gender Fluidity, suggests that gender can evolve based on one’s experiences and feelings.
But Why The Need To Change Gender?
Why is there a need to separate gender from assigned sex? What compels an individual to change his gender identity?
The answer lies in Gender Roles. According to the transgender movement, genders are societal constructs that dictate behaviour based on one’s sex.
For example, men are traditionally seen as strong and assertive. In contrast, women are seen as nurturing and focused on domestic duties. Since individualism values personal choice over societal expectations, people feel they should be free to change their gender if they don’t identify with their assigned roles.
Gender & Sex: Where Does Islam Stand?
Islam has a clear stance: your sex is your gender, and there are only two genders—male and female. While Islam also acknowledges intersex individuals (known as Kuntha in Islamic jurisprudence), they have their specific laws.
Regarding genders, the Quran says:
يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّاسُ إِنَّا خَلَقْنَـٰكُم مِّن ذَكَرٍۢ وَأُنثَىٰ وَجَعَلْنَـٰكُمْ شُعُوبًۭا وَقَبَآئِلَ لِتَعَارَفُوٓا۟ ۚ إِنَّ أَكْرَمَكُمْ عِندَ ٱللَّهِ أَتْقَىٰكُمْ ۚ
“O mankind! Indeed, We created you from a male and a female and made you nations and tribes so that you may know one another. Indeed, the noblest of you in the sight of Allah is the most God-conscious among you.”[Surah al-Hujarat, Verse 13]
Allah not only recognises genders in the Quran, He celebrates them. In Surah al-Nisa, Allah says:
يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلنَّاسُ ٱتَّقُوا۟ رَبَّكُمُ ٱلَّذِى خَلَقَكُم مِّن نَّفْسٍۢ وَٰحِدَةٍۢ وَخَلَقَ مِنْهَا زَوْجَهَا وَبَثَّ مِنْهُمَا رِجَالًۭا كَثِيرًۭا وَنِسَآءًۭ ۚ
“O mankind! Be conscious of your Lord, who created you from a single soul and created its mate from it, and spread many men and women from them.”[Surah Nisa, Verse 1]
Problems with Gender Choices
1. Limits personal freedom: Although an individual might identify with a different gender, this choice can have significant implications for others. For example, if a biological male identifies as female and uses female restrooms, it can cause discomfort and privacy concerns for the women.
From an Islamic perspective, it complicates issues of modesty and hijab, forcing Muslim women to observe hijab even in spaces solely intended for them.
2. Disturbs Family Structure: The traditional roles of a father and mother play a crucial part in a child’s upbringing. If a parent frequently changes his/her gender identity based on personal preference, it can create confusion and instability in the family dynamic, affecting the child’s sense of security and understanding of family roles.
3. Lack of Scientific Support: The concept of separating sex from gender is not observed in any other species in the animal kingdom. Animals naturally adhere to the gender roles assigned by nature based on their biological sex at birth. This suggests that gender roles are not solely a social construct but also have a basis in biological and natural instincts.
4. Reinforces Stereotypes: The concept of gender identity is self-contradictory in some respects. While it aims to challenge traditional gender roles imposed by society, it often leads individuals to adopt the roles and behaviours traditionally associated with their chosen gender, reinforcing the very stereotypes they initially sought to reject.
5. Inconsistent Logic: The philosophy of individualism, which provides the basis for gender identity, does not extend to other aspects of identity like age, race, or nationality. For example, a 60-year-old cannot simply identify as a 15-year-old, nor can someone change their ethnic background or get a new citizenship. This inconsistency raises questions about the limits of self-identification.
6. Creates Social Disruption:The increasing number of gender identities has the potential to create confusion and instability in society. This is already becoming evident in areas like sports, where debates over fairness and eligibility are intensifying due to differing gender identities among athletes.
To understand why Islam opposes choosing a gender separate from the one given by Allah, one needs to understand the several challenges and limitations this concept brings – some being against the very idea that brought it: Individualism.
From an Islamic perspective, the concept of gender fluidity creates significant challenges in the application of Islamic laws. For instance, if a biologically male individual chooses to identify as female and joins the women’s section in a congregational prayer, this action could invalidate the prayers of all the women present. This disrupts the sanctity of worship and undermines the clear guidelines laid out in Islamic jurisprudence.
Gender Roles: How Islam Solves This Problem
Islam addresses the issue of gender roles by shifting the focus from societal expectations to the mutual understanding between the foundational units of society: the husband and wife. While Islam provides a framework that recommends specific roles for each partner in a marriage, it allows for flexibility and mutual agreement between the couple.
For instance, Islam traditionally prescribes that the man should be the primary provider, responsible for the financial needs of the family. At the same time, the woman is encouraged to focus on managing the household. However, Islam allows the couple to reach a mutual agreement where the husband takes care of the house, and the wife takes care of the financial needs – provided they are adhering to other laws obligated to them.
So, instead of making the genders fluid, Islam makes the roles fluid.
This idea of mutual agreement can be seen in the marital life of Imam Ali and Lady Fatima Zahra (alaihimus salaam). At the time of their marriage, they mutually agreed that Imam Ali would carry out the work outside of the home while Lady Fatima would manage the house. Hence, as far as the genders complement each other, Islam does not have a problem if they adjust their roles.
Sexes in Islam: Different but Equal
Many people believe that Islam has kept women as subordinates of men. Verse 34 of Surah Nisa is often quoted for this purpose, mistranslating Qawwamoon as authority. However, the fact is that it means caregiver or protector. Islam has given it an obligation on men to take care of the females around them and provide them with the necessary support.
Islam recognises the inherent differences between men and women in biology, physiology, and psychology, which naturally lead to different rights, responsibilities, and roles within society. However, these differences do not imply that one gender is superior. Islam upholds the principle that while men and women have different functions, they are equal in their value and the eyes of Allah.
This ‘different but equal’ can beautifully be seen in a story from the time of the Holy Prophet Muhammad (sallalahu alaihe wa’alehi). Umm Salama, the wife of the Prophet, complained that men have more opportunities to earn spiritual rewards as they engage in Jihad and sacrifice their lives for Allah.
On this occasion, Allah revealed a verse of the Quran:
فَاسْتَجَابَ لَهُمْ رَبُّهُمْ أَنِّي لَا أُضِيعُ عَمَلَ عَامِلٍ مِنْكُمْ مِنْ ذَكَرٍ أَوْ أُنْثَىٰ ۖ بَعْضُكُمْ مِنْ بَعْضٍ ۖ
Then their Lord answered them, ‘I do not waste the work of any worker among you, whether male or female; you are all on the same footing.[Surah Aal-Imran, Verse 195]
Similarly, in another verse, Allah states
وَمَنْ يَعْمَلْ مِنَ الصَّالِحَاتِ مِنْ ذَكَرٍ أَوْ أُنْثَىٰ وَهُوَ مُؤْمِنٌ فَأُولَٰئِكَ يَدْخُلُونَ الْجَنَّةَ وَلَا يُظْلَمُونَ نَقِيرًا
And whoever does righteous deeds, whether male or female, should he be faithful—such shall enter paradise and they will not be wronged [so much as] the speck on a date-stone.[Surah Nisa, Verse 124]
Genders: A Mean to Reach Allah
In Islam, life is not about altering one’s identity to fit personal desires or societal expectations; instead, it is about embracing the divine role we are given. By accepting and striving within the roles set by Allah (subhanahu wa ta’ala), both men and women can excel in their faith, serve humanity, and earn their place in the sight of their Creator. In Islam, true success lies not in redefining who we are but in becoming the best version of ourselves within the framework Allah (subhanahu wa ta’ala) has designed for us.
Support Thaqlain
These initiatives by Thaqlain are not possible without your support! Be our Monthly Patron to help us keep going!
