What Islam Says About Astrology

This blog is created using Sayed Mohammad Baqer Qazwini’s lecture given at the Muslim Youth Connection (linked here) and is dedicated In memory of Osman Issa.

Join us in finding Islam’s answer to pressing questions of our time. Sponsor a blog in memory/honour of your loved ones by visiting https://thaqlain.org/wisa/.

An estimated 70 million people in the United States check their horoscopes daily. And nearly one-third of the population believes astrology impacts their lives. While science does not support the idea that the position of the sun, moon or planet influences personality or life events, belief in astrology is still popular—especially among Millennials and Generation Z.

But why do so many people turn to astrology? Can the celestial bodies truly shape our lives? And most importantly, what does Islam have to say about these practices?

Astrology vs Astronomy: What’s The Difference?

Before exploring why people are drawn to astrology, it’s crucial to distinguish it from astronomy. While both involve the study of celestial bodies such as stars, moons, and planets, their purposes — and Islam’s stance on them — are fundamentally different.

Astrology is a belief system that suggests stars, planets, and constellations influence individual lives. Astrologers claim to predict various aspects of life—such as relationships, careers, health, and future occurrences—based on the positions and movements of these celestial bodies.

Astronomy, by contrast, is a scientific discipline that uses research and data to understand the universe beyond Earth’s atmosphere. This includes studying the positions of celestial bodies to predict natural phenomena like eclipses or planetary alignments. However, astronomers do not make prophecies about people’s personalities or future events; their focus remains grounded in empirical evidence.

Why Are People Drawn to Astrology?

Historically, astrologers played a significant role in aristocratic circles. Kings and rulers often employed them to anticipate potential threats to their reign. For these leaders, astrology was not just about making predictions; it also provided a convenient way to shift blame for their poor decisions onto celestial forces, absolving them of any responsibility.

Even today, many people are drawn to astrology because it helps make sense of the unknown. The desire to attribute life’s uncertainties to external forces that are beyond one’s control makes astrology particularly appealing. Research has shown that during times of stress or anxiety, people are more likely to turn to astrology for guidance. This explains why belief in astrology surged during the COVID-19 pandemic: people sought answers when no one else could provide them. (Reference)

Islamic Perspective on Astrology

Islam acknowledges the stars, planets, and other celestial bodies as signs of Allah’s majesty and creation. While it encourages the idea to study these celestial bodies and their impact on life on Earth, Islam clarifies that stars and planets do not control human destiny, and the final authority resides with Allah (The most glorified, the most high).

Astrology in the Eyes of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him & his progeny)

A profound incident during the Hudaibiyah expedition, found in both Sunni and Shia sources, highlights Islam’s stance on astrology. On one of the nights of the journey, it rained, and some companions attributed the event to the influence of a particular star. After leading the Fajr prayer, the Prophet addressed his companions and asked:

“Do you know what your Lord has said?”

When they replied, “Allah and His Messenger know best,” he explained:

إن ربكم يقول: من عبادي مؤمن بي وكافر بالكواكب، وكافر بي ومؤمن بالكواكب، فمن قال: مطرنا بفضل الله ورحمته .فذلك مؤمن بي وكافر بالكواكب، ومن قال: مطرنا بنوء كذا وكذا، فذلك كافر بي ومؤمن بالكواكب.

“Your Lord says: Among My servants are those who believe in Me and disbelieve in the stars, and among them are those who disbelieve in Me and believe in the stars. Whoever says, ‘We have been granted rain by the grace and mercy of Allah,’ that one believes in Me and disbelieves in the stars. But whoever says, ‘We have been granted rain because of such-and-such star,’ that one disbelieves in Me and believes in the stars.“

[Wasail al-Shia, Vol. 11, Pg. 374]

Rejection of Astrology in Nahjul Balagha

The Ahlulbayt consistently rejected the idea that celestial positions could dictate human outcomes. A well-known example comes from Imam Ali (peace be upon him) during the Battle of Nahrawan. When an astrologer warned against travelling at a specific hour due to unfavourable star alignments, the Imam firmly responded:

أتزعم أنك تهدى إلى الساعة التي من سار فيها صرف عنه السوء، وتخوف من الساعة التي من سار فيها حاق به الضر! فمن صدقك بهذا فقد كذب القرآن، واستغنى عن الاستعانة بالله في نيل المحبوب ودفع المكروه. وتبتغي في قولك للعامل بأمرك أن يوليك الحمد دون ربه، لأنك – بزعمك – أنت هديته إلى الساعة التي نال فيها النفع، وأمن الضر.

“Do you think you can tell the time when a man goes out and no evil befall him or can warn of the time at which if one goes out harm will accrue? Whoever testifies to this falsifies the Qur’an and becomes unmindful of Allah in achieving his desired objective and in warding off the undesirable. You cherish saying this so that he who acts on what you say should praise you rather than Allah because according to your misconception you have guided him about the hour in which he would secure benefit and avoid harm.”

Imam Ali not only rejected the astrologer’s warning but also addressed his companions, cautioning against relying on astrology:

أيها الناس، إياكم وتعلم النجوم إلا ما يهتدى به في بر أو بحر، فإنها تدعو إلى الكهانة، المنجم كالكاهن، والكاهن كالساحر، والساحر كالكافر، والكافر في النار، سيروا على اسم الله.

“O People! Beware of learning the science of stars except that with which guidance is sought on land or sea, because it leads to divining and an astrologer is a diviner, while the diviner is like the sorcerer, the sorcerer is like the unbeliever and the unbeliever would be in Hell. Get forward in the name of Allah.”

[Nahjul Balagha, Sermon 79]

Imam Ali then marched as planned and achieved a decisive victory in the Battle of Nahrawan, proving that astrological calculations made by humans had no cause and effect.

Does Islam Reject Astrology Entirely?

Interestingly, while rejecting the deterministic power of celestial bodies, some narrations from Ahlulbayt do acknowledge that stars may serve as signs of certain realities. For instance:

  • On the night of his martyrdom, Imam Ali (peace be upon him) walked to his courtyard multiple times, observed the skies and remarked, ‘By Lord, it is indeed the night promised by my beloved Messenger of Allah’.
  • Similarly, certain hadiths discourage specific actions, such as performing a marriage contract during the “Scorpio stage” of the lunar cycle (Qamar dar Aqrab), due to its potential negative effects.

When these examples are viewed collectively, it becomes clear that Islam’s issue with astrology lies not in the acknowledgement of celestial signs but in astrologers claiming to predict the future without divine authority. Since Allah (the Most Glorified, the Most High) has not shared this knowledge with humans, anyone—except the Prophet, his progeny, or angels—claiming to understand the impact of celestial bodies on human lives is merely engaging in speculation.

If Predicting the Future Is Haraam, What About Istikhara?

In Islam, taking guidance from Allah whenever you are stuck in a difficult situation is known as Istikhara or Khira. It is a concept that can be found in the hadith of the Ahlulbayt.

But is it fortune-telling? Absolutely not! Istikhara involves prayer and reliance on Allah’s divinity to determine the best course of action. In other words, it is seeking Allah’s guidance when clarity eludes reasoned decision-making. It does not tell you whether a certain thing will bring you good fortune or bad. Instead, it is merely asking Allah if a particular thing is in your interest or not.

Challenges of Engaging with Astrology

As humans, we often tend to believe in things even when we know they are not true.

A famous story about Sheikh al-Tusi illustrates this. Once, when his students wanted to postpone class for a day, they entered the classroom one by one, asking the Sheikh if he was alright because he appeared pale. After several students expressed concern, Sheikh al-Tusi eventually decided to cancel the class as he began to feel that he might actually be sick.

Similarly, it’s very easy, even for those who do not believe in astrology’s claims, to become accustomed to its language and ideas. Since, the belief in astrology is so widely spread in society, ideas start to subtly influence our faith and actions.

1. Shirk: Elevating Stars to Deities

Historically, astrology has led some to associate divine power with celestial bodies. In ancient civilisations, people believed that stars, planets, or constellations governed their lives, even worshipping them as deities.

While modern astrology may not involve explicit worship, attributing undue significance to celestial movements can echo these past errors, undermining faith in Allah as the sole authority.

2. Helplessness: The Illusion of Predetermination

Astrology fosters the idea that events and personal traits are predetermined by celestial alignments. This can lead to a dangerous sense of helplessness, where individuals feel powerless to shape their destiny.

When someone begins to think, “I cannot succeed because I was born under an unlucky star,” or believes that difficulties are due to planetary movements, they undermine the Islamic ethos of striving, praying, and trusting in Allah. Over time, this mindset can lead to despair and inaction, directly opposing the Quranic message of hope and empowerment.

3. Prejudice: Preconceived Notions and Justifications

Astrology often generalises people’s personalities based on their zodiac signs, creating stereotypical labels such as “Geminis are unreliable” or “Scorpios are naturally manipulative.” These stereotypes foster prejudice as individuals develop preconceived notions about others based on arbitrary astrological categories.

What’s worse is that astrology can justify one’s own negative traits or actions under the guise of “I was born this way.” For instance, someone might excuse their harmful behaviour by saying, “I’m a Leo; I can’t help but be domineering.” This mentality contradicts Islam’s teachings, which hold individuals accountable for their actions and call them to constantly strive for self-improvement.

The Subtle Erosion of Faith and Accountability

Even casual interest in astrology can subtly alter how one views oneself, others, and their relationship with Allah. By ascribing influence to the stars, one risks replacing divine reliance with superstition. By feeling powerless under “astrological fate,” one may abandon the principle of free will. And by allowing astrology to dictate judgments about others, one may violate Islam’s emphasis on justice and individual accountability.

Islam calls believers to rise above such influences, focusing instead on building a direct relationship with Allah through prayer, effort, and trust in His wisdom. Ultimately, astrology distracts from this path, leading the heart and mind away from true faith and self-determination.

Support Thaqlain

These initiatives by Thaqlain are not possible without your support! Be our Monthly Patron to help us keep going!

[thaqlain_follow]